‘Dune’ tried to warn us against AI

Even the biggest fans of


Dune


know that Frank Herbert’s classic sci-fi epic quickly veers into the fantastical. Giant subterranean

sandworms

measuring 1,500 feet long; a narcotic that fuels interstellar travel and bends a user’s perception of space-time; a mystical cabal of eugenicist witches—the list goes on. But there is at least one story within the sprawling series that feels increasingly like a premonition rather than plot point: the

Butlerian Jihad

.

Taking place well before the events of

Dune

itself, the Butlerian Jihad was a nearly century-long, interplanetary revolt that saw humanity racing to destroy all of its advanced computers,

artificial intelligence systems

, and other “thinking machines.” The underlying cause wasn’t that sentient robots were attempting to eradicate humans, however. Instead, our species’ overreliance on the programs had generated an upper ruling class of technocrats that soon presided over all aspects of society. It wasn’t so much that humanity was afraid of

AI

, as much as they were afraid of the people who designed and controlled the AI. The Butlerian Jihad ultimately resulted in the obliteration of all thinking machines, as well as a wholesale ban on any new robotic creations.

“Thou shalt not make a machine in the likeness of a human mind,” reads one of the ensuing, in-universe religious texts.

Dune

’s author didn’t necessarily intend the Butlerian Jihad to be an ominous warning. If anything, it was a clever way to bypass dealing with distant future

AI

concepts and focus on Herbert’s interests in power dynamics, gender, and societal structures. Even so, it’s hard not to get a

little

weirded out by a passage from

Dune

that is once again

making the rounds on social media

.

“Once men turned their thinking over to machines in the hope that this would set them free. But that only permitted other men with machines to enslave them,” a character explained to protagonist Paul Atreides early in the first novel.

Whether or not life imitates art remains to be seen. That said, there’s no reason not to poke some fun at the current generation of supposed AI in the meantime:

And even if subjugation isn’t in the cards, there is an increasing

body of evidence

that suggests too much time with “thinking machines” is already starting to

affect our own cognitive abilities

.

2025 PopSci Best of What’s New

The 50 most important innovations of the year

See it